Opposition Leader: October 9 Opera House Protest Crime “…Akin To A Port Arthur Moment…” In Social Significance

Last Wednesday night, at the Tom Hughes Oration, a public speaking Liberal party fundraiser for the Federal seat of Berowra, held at the Sydney Opera House’s Studio, the Opposition Leader of Australia, Peter Dutton, compared the social significance of the crime that occurred at pro-Arab protests at the Sydney Opera House on the 9th of October last year during an Israeli Solidarity Opera House Western Sails Illumination after the attack on that state by Hamas to that of the 1996 Port Arthur massacre in Tasmania, describing both event’s social significance as “akin” to one another:

While no one was killed during the October 9 protests, the events at the Sydney Opera House were akin to a Port Arthur moment in terms of their social significance.

In my judgement, Prime Minister Albanese has not risen to that moment.

Peter Dutton, Opposition Leader Of Australia

On 28th of April 1996, 35 people were killed & 23 others were wounded in a mass shooting at Port Arthur, Tasmania, prompting then-Prime Minister John Howard, who was only elected to office just over a month prior, to significantly amend Australia’s gun laws.

Tom Hughes, a Liberal politician, was Australia’s Attorney-General from 1967 to 1971.

The next morning, Peter Dutton made a press conference where he was questioned on his statement by an Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC) journalist:

Do you stand by comparing the pro-Palestinian rally on the steps of the Opera House last year to the Port Arthur massacre? How is the social significance of these 2 events in any way comparable?

Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC) Journalist

The Opposition Leader responded saying he would not have tolerated antisemitic protests, just as he would not tolerate any other minority-directed hatred:

I, I, I made the very important point last night that in 1996 when we saw a tragic loss of life, uh, in Port Arthur with that massacre there that John Howard, the Prime Minister at the time stood up & was strong as a leader, not weak.

He stood up for what was right, not what was wrong & he led the Australian public on a path that we still benefit from today. That is, gun law reform & we had a chance, I think, for the Prime Minister to see the controversy that was created, uh, after October 7 in our country, those dreadful scenes on the steps of the Opera House.

Uh, fortunately there’s no loss of life in our country, uh, as a result of that protest, of course, no one is suggesting there is but what we saw was a rise in antisemitism where we’ve got armed guards outside schools, at the moment, in our country. There are people of Jewish faith who are worried about going to a synagogue or worried about going to a Jewish supermarket or gathering in communities. We’ve got Holocaust survivors who sought refuge in our country & have felt safe for decades under Liberal and Labor Governments, are now talking about wanting to leave Australia because they feel unsafe so, yes, did I think John Howard stood up in ’96 when he needed to in our country’s interests?

Absolutely & did Anthony Albanese stand up and show the strength John Howard demonstrated and change the course of our country’s history? No, he didn’t. He was weak. He’s been trying to walk both sides of the street when it comes to this issue. He’s trying to tell people in Western Sydney 1 story and people in Dover Heights a completely different story & Australians are seeing through it.

Peter Dutton, Opposition Leader Of Australia

John Howard, who comes from the same Liberal-Nationals Coalition as Peter Dutton, was Prime Minister (PM) of Australia from 1996 before being replaced by Labor’s Kevin Rudd in 2007. Party in-fighting saw a leadership spill in 2010. Australia’s Deputy PM, Julia Gillard, replace Kevin Rudd. in June 2010, who was 3 years later, replaced by Kevin Rudd after more party in-fighting resulted in another leadership spill. Kevin Rudd and his Labor party lost the Federal election & thus, the Prime Ministership less than 3 months later in September 2013.

Dover Heights is a suburb in eastern Sydney, where just about half (49.9%) of the population follows the religion of Judaism while western Sydney has a significant Arab minority with at least 8% following the religion of Islam.

I think the point of that question though is the events that were compared are very different.

Unknown ABC Journalist

But, but, hang on, look, look at the comments that I made, uh & you can’t, the basis of that question that has come out of Canberra, uh, is obviously a Canberra-based question from the ABC. If you look at the facts of what I said, I don’t think you can have the, the, the, the, presumption in that question that you asked so I would say to whoever it is from the Canberra bureau, uh, to look at what I had to say last night because I think they’ve set you up with that question if I’ve might say.

Peter Dutton, Opposition Leader Of Australia

Canberra is the capital city of Australia and thus, the home of Australian Federal political news bureaus.

Well, Mike Burgess last year said ‘words matter’ when maintaining social cohesion in Australia. Did you breach that advice in your speech last night?

Unknown ABC Journalist

Mike Burgess is Director-General of Security at the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation.

As Mike Burgess said, no. Again, the Labor Party were running this line through the ABC last year and Mike Burgess came out to say he was making no reference to comments that I made whatsoever so, I’m not going to be tarnished by the ABC. I’m not going to cower because of the ABC and other left wing media organisations in our country. My job is to stand up for what is best in our country’s interests. My job is to share our vision with the Australian people about what we want for the future of our country.

Peter Dutton, Opposition Leader Of Australia

We understand Mike Burgess has not responded to Peter Dutton’s recent social significance comparison. Port Arthur’s Federal Parliament member, the Member For Lyons, Brian Williams, responded to Mr Dutton’s comments though:

From the unspeakable tragedy & horror of what occurred at Port Arthur in 1996, the Australian people put politics aside and came together in common purpose.

As the local member here, I would ask Peter Dutton to reflect on that & refrain from making such divisive and inflammatory comments using the tragedy in our community.

Brian Williams, Member For Lyons.

Sydney Opera House To Have Black Ribbon Projection In Tribute To 6 Victims Of Bondi Junction Stabbings

The New South Wales (NSW) Government has announced the Sydney Opera House will feature a projection of a black ribbon on its World Heritage sails from 6pm Australian Eastern Standard Time tonight in tribute to the 6 victims of the stabbings at Westfield Bondi Junction shopping centre on Saturday afternoon.

8 people including a 9-month-old baby still remain in hospital in a stable but for 3, including the 9-month-old baby, serious condition. 2 of which are in intensive care.

Due to how this projection came about, this projection will not be considered a Sydney Spectacular.

You can watch it live here.

I have to report that the Opera House this evening will be lit up with a black, uh, ribbon to commemorate the loss of those lives & Government buildings will be flying their flags at half-mast.

Chris Minns, NSW Premier

Independent Biometric Scientist Finds “Where’s The Jews?” Rather Than “Gas The Jews” Was Chanted In Opera House Protest Recordings As Protester Spared Common Assault Conviction

On behalf of New South Wales (NSW) Police, an independent biometric scientist has completed a forensic analysis of “significant volumes” of audio & video files of the pro-Arab Sydney Opera House protest that occurred on the 9th of October last year during an Israeli Solidarity Opera House Western Sails Illumination after the attack on that state by Hamas. They found no evidence the widely reported phrase, “Gas the Jews”, was being chanted throughout the audio & videos.

The analysis was done by Michael Wagner, honorary professor at the Australian National University and emeritus professor at Canberra University. He told The Sydney Morning Herald that the analysis of the 11 reported chants of “Gas the Jews” “has resulted in overwhelming certainty that all…consist of the phrase ‘Where’s the Jews?’.”

As a result of that examination, the expert has concluded with overwhelming certainty that the phrase chanted during that protest as recorded on the audio & visual files was “Where’s the Jews?”. Not another phrase as otherwise widely reported.

NSW Police Deputy Commissioner, Mal Lanyon

The footage purporting to play the “Gas the Jews” chant was first posted online by the Australian Jewish Association. However, NSW Police Deputy Commissioner, Mal Lanyon, clarified NSW Police did not believe the footage was doctored but had been incorrectly captioned. He also said some witnesses had reported hearing the offensive chant, but they had “not been able to ascribe those words to any individual”. Deputy Commissioner Lanyon also said there was evidence that other offensive phrases were said during the protest including the phrase “F–k the Jews”.

NSW Premier, Chris Minns, also said his views had not changed & the protest “was violent and racist”.

Hate speech and racist language have no place in NSW. If those comments were made about any other group, my reaction would be the same.

NSW Premier, Chris Minns

We know what we heard & the world knows what was said. However, the exact words used in these chants is not the core issue. The core issue is that on October 9, before Israel had even commenced its military response, just 2 days after the greatest atrocity inflicted on the Jewish people since the Holocaust, a mob of thugs gathered at one of our nation’s most cherished sites to celebrate the mass slaughter and rape of Israelis, to burn Israeli flags & to chant threateningly towards fellow Australians.

Executive Council of Australian Jewry Co-Chief Executive, Alex Ryvchin

Sydney Spectaculars can find no evidence that the pro-Arab protest “gathered” at the Opera House to “celebrate” but rather to protest the lighting of the western Opera House sails in the colours of the Israeli flag.

NSW Police said in a statement to The Sydney Morning Herald that detectives “continue to investigate the incident”.

In related news from a month ago, pro-Arab protester, Marcel Ghabbar, 31, has been spared conviction of his charge of 1 count of common assault, at the same protest as mentioned above, according to Mosman Daily.

At that time, a 45-year-old man, Anatoly Kirievsky, yelled “You’re all f**king terrorists” allegedly trying to agitate the Opera House protesters. He became involved in an argument with a male group. During the argument, amongst other alleged assaults by other protesters, Anatoly Kirievsky was then shoved by Marcel Ghabbar. Police intervened & the arguers then dispersed and left the Sydney Opera House. Anatoly Kirievsky then reported the alleged assaults to Maroubra Police.

NSW Police later released, on the 17th of October, closed circuit television images of 5 people, 4 male & 1 female, they believe would be able to assist with the investigation into the alleged assaults. Later that day, Marcel Ghabber attended Mosman Police Station where he was arrested & at 11pm, were taken to Day Street Police Station where he was later charged with common assault. The court case begun on November 8 last year.

Marcel Ghabbar, 31, leaving Downing Centre Local Court on the 8th of November 2023.
Photograph: Dean Lewins/Australian Associated Press

Sydney Opera House Lit In Tribute To Barry Humphries

The western sails of the Sydney Opera House were lit up themed to Dame Edna Everage last night in tribute to the life of iconic comedic star, Barry Humphries.

The sails were lit between 8:30pm & Midnight.

Barry Humphries played many comedic characters over his career but his most iconic included Dame Edna Everage & Sir Les Patterson. He also voiced Bruce the Great White Shark in the iconic Pixar computer animated film, Finding Nemo. Barry Humphries passed away on the 22nd of April this year, aged 89.

Sydney Opera House To Be Lit In Tribute To Barry Humphries Tonight

At today’s State Memorial for Barry Humphries at the Sydney Opera House, the Master of Ceremonies, Richard Wilkins, revealed the western sails of the Sydney Opera House will be lit up tonight in tribute to the comedy star.

A photo from a rehearsal of the projection was shown at the State Memorial, which can be found above. It reveals the projection is themed to his iconic character, Dame Edna Everage.

The sails will be lit from 8:30pm.

Richard Wilkins was host of the Sydney New Year’s Eve television broadcast in 1996, 1997 &from 2000-2005.

Barry Humphries played many comedic characters over his career but his most iconic included Dame Edna Everage & Sir Les Patterson.

‘Sydney Spectaculars’ Newsletter Trial

UPDATE: Feedback will now close on the 19th of January.

Sydney Spectaculars has begun trialling a new newsletter as part of a wider review into the website.

In the menu, you will find a subscription block. Sometimes, it may also appear while browsing the site like towards the end of an article (see picture above). Enter your e-mail address and then you can choose what articles get sent to you based on your interest.

You can choose everything or what just interests you (see picture above). For example:

  • ‘Flagship’ Sydney Spectaculars refer to major events of Sydney that are held annually or biannually &have a ‘wow’ factor. There are currently 5 such events – Sydney New Year’s Eve, Vivid Sydney, Australia Day In Sydney, Airshows Downunder Shellharbour & State Of Origin.
  • ‘Extraordinary’ Sydney Spectaculars refer to major events of Sydney that are held less frequently than annually but also have a ‘wow’ factor. Currently, the most well-known type of event this category involves are the Navy reviews – the last of which was held a decade ago.
  • ‘Other’ Sydney Spectaculars refer to events of Sydney that are more frequent than being held on an annual basis or are annual but do not have a ‘wow’ factor currently. The most well-known event of the former would be ‘Badu Gili: Wonder Woman‘, a near-nightly projection show on the Bennelong Sail of the Sydney Opera House while the latter would include events like Sydney Lunar Festival.

You can also choose a specific event if you are only interested in a certain event too.

We will change our home page in the next week to a static home page where you can click on the events you are most interested in and you can see the latest updates there.

All of this is so we can provide more event news to you more frequently. The current home page set-up only allows a focus of 1 story and so publication of new stories has been limited to a maximum 1 per day to give each story at least 24 hours for our readers to read.

The menu on the left has also been simplified regarding Sydney New Year’s Eve particularly given the ‘revolutions’ now evolve through Vivid Sydney rather than Sydney New Year’s Eve. To find the Sydney New Year’s Eve fireworks soundtracks, just click ‘History’.

We are also happy to take on any ideas that will help improve the site. If you have an idea, submit it here! Feedback closes on 19th January 2024. If you miss the deadline, you can always e-mail us.

All these changes & the larger review is due to the major changes coming to these events in the short-term. We started back in 2011 initially with Sydney New Year’s Eve – everyone’s favourite – then Vivid Sydney became popular in the mid-2010’s & now 3 extra major events have been added as ‘flagship’ Sydney Spectaculars in the past 5 years. We never expected Sydney’s events to grow so much more spectacular since we started what was an archival YouTube channel & is now this site dedicated to these iconic events. The interest from around the world on these events is extraordinary. We hope these changes will make finding information on these jaw-dropping events easier for all.

New South Wales Police Send Israel Solidarity Illumination Pro-Arab Protest Video Away For “Independent, Expert Analysis”

On November 28, The Sydney Morning Herald reported that New South Wales (NSW) Police have sent a video, of the controversial pro-Arab protest that occurred at the Southern Forecourt of the Sydney Opera House on the night the World Heritage site was lit up in the colours of the Israeli flag in solidarity with that country after an attack on it by Hamas, away for “independent, expert analysis”, as part of Operation Mealing.

A NSW Police spokesperson told The Sydney Morning Herald that investigations into the alleged chanting of the anti-semitic phrase “Gas the Jews” at that protest were ongoing:

NSW Police are yet to confirm wording used during the October 9, 2023 protest. Investigators have sent a video recording for independent, expert analysis. No person has been charged with speaking the words “Gas the Jews”.

NSW Police Spokesperson

According to The Sydney Morning Herald, NSW Police did not confirm if the video of the protesters allegedly chanting “Gas the Jews” was the video that had been sent for “independent, expert analysis”.

Trio Charged With Alleged Opera House Illumination Common Assault Face Court, 1 Makes Plea (Not Guilty) As Lawyer Requests CCTV Footage

Marcel Ghabbar and Justen Abdul-Khalek, both aged 31 & Omar El-Sobihy, 19, (pictured above) faced Sydney’s Downing Centre Local Court on Wednesday, November the 8th.

Omar El-Sobihy’s lawyer, on his client’s behalf, entered into pleas of not guilty for his client’s 2 common assault charges & told the Court, he was seeking to view closed-circuit television (CCTV) footage captured of the alleged attack.

Marcel Ghabbar & Justen Abdul-Khalek are yet to enter a plea to their respective charges of 1 count of common assault each.

Marcel Ghabbar (left) and Justen Abdul-Khalek (right), both 31, leaving Downing Centre Local Court.
Photograph: Dean Lewins/Australian Associated Press

On the 17th of October, NSW Police reported they are investigating an alleged assault that occurred at the Sydney Opera House when the Israeli flag colours were illuminated on the World Heritage Site’s sails on the 9th of October at 7:30pm.

At that time, a 45-year-old man allegedly became involved in an argument with a male group. The man during the alleged argument was then allegedly assaulted and spat on. Police intervened & the arguers then dispersed and left the Sydney Opera House.

The 45-year-old man then reported the alleged assault to Maroubra Police. The next day, Operation Mealing investigators were notified & commenced an investigation. By 18th October, 3 men were charged with a total of 4 counts of common assault, who then attended Court as detailed above.

The matters are due to return to court on Friday the 8th of December.

NSW Police Wanted Counter-Terrorism Threat Assessment Before Premier’s Decision To Light Up Opera House Blue & White In Solidarity With Israel After Hamas Attack

At a New South Wales (NSW) Legislative Council Budget Estimates hearing on Tuesday the 7th of November 2023, NSW Police Deputy Commissioner, David Hudson, under questioning from Sarah Mitchell, a Nationals Legislative Councillor, confirmed that NSW Police wanted a counter-terrorism threat assessment before the NSW Premier, Chris Minns, made his final decision on whether to light up the Sydney Opera House blue & white in solidarity with Israel after the Hamas attack on that country.

NSW Police Deputy Commissioner, David Hudson, was the Acting Commissioner at the time of the Opera House Israel Solidarity Illumination on the 9th of October.

The (Police) Minister said this morning that it wasn’t envisaged that there was any heightened risk at that point. That was on the Sunday. Is that your recollection as well?

Sarah Mitchell, Nationals Legislative Councillor

Uh, that’s correct. Um, at the time I asked for the threat assessment, um, I wanted that to inform me whether we had concerns or not (faint chuckle), um, so at that stage I just wanted the assessment, I didn’t have particular concerns. I was aware that, um, other, uh — & that, that was in response to being told by the chief of staff that was consideration being made to light the sails of the Opera House with the Israeli flag, um, but, uh, at that stage, um, there were no concerns that had been relayed to me & I didn’t have the, the threat assessment from Counterterrorism at that stage, but, um, as I said, other, other icons around the world had been lit up, I was led to believe.

David Hudson, NSW Police Deputy Commissioner

So how did the police find out about the lighting of the Opera House
sails & in his evidence, the Premier said it may have been through the media? Are you-Do you know how that information made its way to the police?

Sarah Mitchell, Nationals Legislative Councillor

Um, my recollection is that after the threat assessment, assessment had been requested, it got processed through to my normal staff officer, um, who was in my normal role, which oversights counterterrorism, um, to request & he responded that “Too late. It was just on the news”.

David Hudson, NSW Police Deputy Commissioner

Ok so, so it was media reports that gave you the confirmation that that had
been the Premier’s decision?

Sarah Mitchell, Nationals Legislative Councillor

Yes. Well, I didn’t actually see the media reports. My norm-

David Hudson, NSW Police Deputy Commissioner

Your staff officer did?

Sarah Mitchell, Nationals Legislative Councillor

My normal staff officer did relay that through an e-mail.

David Hudson, NSW Police Deputy Commissioner

On the afternoon of Monday the 9th of October, NSW Police became aware that a protest to be held on Monday the 9th of October at Sydney Town Hall would now also include a march to the Sydney Opera House & that people who didn’t attend the Town Hall protest were also invited to show up at the Opera House protest too.

Later in the hearing, NSW Police Deputy Commissioner David Hudson, revealed that the Opera House protest had a reserve police force of 100 officers:

Um, in terms of the police operations on both the 9th of October & then also on the 15th of October, I know that the Premier, um, made some public comments saying that there would be more police available for a later rally that took place in Hyde Park, is my recollection. What-What’s the cost of the police operations to do that & the difference between what occurred on the 9th and the 15th? Do you have that information?

Sarah Mitchell, Nationals Legislative Councillor

Um, ma’am, only from the, uhm, cost of the actual police shifts that were deployed, I think there was 100 at the October 9th with another 100 in reserve, um, at the Opera House & then on the, uh, on the following Saturday, uh, so-the following Sunday there were over 1,000 police so their shifts — the difference would be significant.

David Hudson, NSW Police Deputy Commissioner

Commissioner Hudson then confirmed the announcement made following the protest to maybe utilise Part 6A of the Law Enforcement (Powers & Responsibilities) Act (LEPRA) 2002 was a direct result of the flare lighting and throwing at the Sydney Opera House protest & that extra police would be required if it was utilised:

The, the, the distinction between having 100 on the 9th and 1000 on the 15th – is that because of lessons learned from the, the Opera House protest or what was the operational decision to mark-significantly increase the police presence on that day?

Sarah Mitchell, Nationals Legislative Councillor

Um, we were going to, uh, potentially & we announced this — potentially, um, utilise, um, Part 6A of LE-LEPRA because of the behaviour that was demonstrated on the 9th of October & the difficulty in investigating potential criminal offences that had taken place on the 9th of October. We were going to activate part of that power under LEPRA to, um, ask for identification of individuals & potentially search some individuals because of flares that were used on the 9th, um, so, uh, it was, uh, believed that we would need additional police for that.

David Hudson, NSW Police Deputy Commissioner

Commissioner Hudson then confirmed that Operation Mealing now reports to Deputy Commissioner Malcolm Lanyon:

That Operation…Mealing now report directly to Mal.

David Hudson, NSW Police Deputy Commissioner